From the presidential race down, Nevada matters. But how much?

Nevada is one of the seven swing states that will decide the election. It’s why presidential candidates and their surrogates keep showing up in the Silver State — and why the “We Matter” mantra has stuck.

But are we essential? That’s a different story.

The Indy analyzed the various scenarios in which Nevadans will decide the next president, as well as control of the U.S. Senate.

There are a few scenarios in which the election will come down to Nevada. There are more where, depending on what happens on the East Coast and in the Midwest, it comes down to us and Arizona. And while it’s unlikely that the counting goes this quickly in the Blue Wall states of Michigan, Pennsylvania and Wisconsin, we could know who the president is before polls even close here.

Here are a few trends to pay attention to in other states to know exactly how much we’ll matter Tuesday night.

Presidential

Vice President Kamala Harris’ simplest path to the presidency is to win Michigan, Pennsylvania and Wisconsin. Former President Donald Trump needs to pick off one of the “Blue Wall” states and then, depending on which one, win two to three of the Sun Belt states.

If the Blue Wall splits, Nevada becomes exponentially more important to each candidate’s calculus. Within that scenario, if Georgia and North Carolina — each worth 16 electoral votes — go to different parties, the likelihood increases that Nevada will be the decider.

There are a few scenarios in which Trump and Harris get three swing states apiece, and the mathematical configuration makes Nevada necessary to get to 270. Two of them require Trump to win Pennsylvania, so if you’re the kind of sicko who only cares about Nevada’s importance and not about the outcome, you should root for that. Those are:

Harris: WI, MI, GA/NC; Trump: PA, AZ, GA/NC
Harris: MI, AZ, GA/NC; Trump: PA, WI, GA/NC
Harris: PA, WI, AZ; Trump: MI, GA, NC

The final scenario is the very unlikely — but not impossible — 269-269 tie. For that to happen, Trump would need to sweep the Blue Wall states, while Harris would take North Carolina, Georgia and Arizona. In that case, if she wins Nevada, she wins the race; if Trump wins Nevada, we’re knotted at 269.

Senate

Republicans will gain a seat in West Virginia, with Republican Gov. Jim Justice’s victory a near certainty in the race to replace retiring Sen. Joe Manchin (I-WV). That puts the Senate, where Democrats currently have a 51-49 majority, at 50-50, and makes every competitive Senate race a potential decider between a tied Senate or a wider majority.

The more that incumbents in other states hold onto their seats, the more likely that Nevada will determine control of the chamber. If Democrats hold seats in Arizona, Maryland, Michigan, Montana, Ohio, Pennsylvania and Wisconsin, and Republicans hold seats in Florida and Texas, then Nevada’s Senate race determines if the chamber is 50-50, if Sen. Jacky Rosen (D-NV) wins, or 51-49 for the GOP, if Republican Sam Brown wins.

Prognosticators expect Republicans to take control of the Senate, with the size of the majority in question. Sens. Jon Tester (D-MT) and Sherrod Brown (D-OH), running in red states where Trump is sure to win, are in the most danger.

If Tester or Brown, or any of the other Democratic incumbents, lose, then the Nevada Senate race will determine exactly how big the Republican majority is. If only Tester loses, for example, then eyes will be on Nevada — a Rosen win, holding the Republican Senate majority at 51-49, would make the handful of Republican moderates among the most powerful people in the upper chamber.

And if Republicans were to gain a seat, but Democrats also pick one up in Texas, Nevada could again be the decider.

A few caveats here. Several states might still be counting ballots by the time polls close in Nevada. So we likely won’t know the exact terrain of the Senate. And a 50-50 Senate is controlled by the president’s party. So if all Democrats hold, including Rosen, but Trump wins the presidency, then Republicans will still control the Senate — and those moderates become even more important, as the likely deciding votes on various policy initiatives. Recall 2017, for example, when a few Republicans, made famous by the late Arizona Republican Sen. John McCain’s famous “thumbs down” vote, joined forces with Democrats to kill a repeal of the Affordable Care Act.

House

We don’t expect to know which party will control the House for quite some time, because a majority in either party is expected to be slim and will hinge on several races in notoriously slow-counting California.

But the lowdown on the House, where Republicans currently have a 220-212 majority, is the following. If Democrats hold their three seats in Las Vegas, it doesn’t necessarily have any implication on a majority. Democrats are expecting to hold those seats; Republicans don’t believe their path runs through Las Vegas, and thus have not spent any money there.

If Republicans do manage to win — even just one seat — then that’s an unexpected pickup and a portent of a good night for the GOP’s odds of keeping, and perhaps even expanding its majority.

This story is used with permission of The Nevada Independent. Go here for updates to this and other Nevada Independent stories.

Top Stories

... or see all stories

Carson City voters who are trying to drop off their mail-in ballots should take them by 5 p.m. Monday to the Carson City Courthouse, 885 East Musser Street.

CARSON CITY — On Monday, Brett Compston, who has worked more than a decade in emergency response at the state and federal level, was named the next chief of Nevada Division of Emergency Management/Homeland Security.

Nevada State Police, Highway Patrol division has identified a Minden man who died in an Oct. 24 single vehicle crash on I-580 and Eastlake Boulevard in Washoe County.

Nevada State Police, Highway Patrol has identified a Gardnerville man who died Oct. 19 from injuries in a crash on I-80 and Robb Drive in Washoe County.

A 30-year-old man was arrested Saturday for suspicion of battery with a deadly weapon after allegedly attacking another man with a meat cleaver, according to a Carson City Sheriff's Office booking report.

In the 2020 election, President Joe Biden was not declared the winner of Nevada’s electoral votes until four days after Election Day.

Is it possible we’ll have to wait that long again?

Advocates to End Domestic Violence, a nonprofit in Carson City offering emergency shelter and various resources for victims of domestic and sexual violence, hosted a ribbon-cutting ceremony Oct. 30 to celebrate the soon to be open, newly constructed shelter facility for survivors in Carson City and surrounding communities.

Join us for "November Jazz at Gina's," an evening of big-band music by the Mile High Jazz Band with singer Jakki Ford, on Tuesday, Nov. 12, 2024, from 7 to 9 p.m., at Gina's Good Life Music & Lounge, 507 N. Carson Street the Carson Nugget. Admission is free; suggested donation is $10 per person for the band.

In an urgent response to fill a longstanding gap in services, the Carson City Rural Child Advocacy Center has begun working with the Carson City Sheriff’s Office to provide immediate support for children who have been victims or witnesses of violent crime, abuse, and exploitation.

Nevada has always been a betting man’s jungle. Before casinos we bet with each other, and here’s how one friendly wager played out on a Saturday afternoon away back in 1862.

The Carson City Sheriff's Office Uniformed Reserves along with the Volunteers In Partnership with the Sheriff (VIPS) proudly participated in the Prescription Drug Take Back Program on Saturday, Oct. 19 at four convenient locations in Carson City.

Erica Gallegos, Program Director for The Nevada Green Business Network, is the featured speaker at the next Rotary Club of Carson City meeting. The public is invited to attend the meeting which takes place Tuesday, Nov. 5, at noon, in the Brewery Arts Center’s Grand Ballroom.

The United Women in Faith invite the community to join them for their annual craft faire, bake sale and vintage market on Saturday, Nov. 9 from 9 am to 2 pm at the First United Methodist Church, 412 W. Musser Street in Carson City.

Nevada is one of the seven swing states that will decide the election. It’s why presidential candidates and their surrogates keep showing up in the Silver State — and why the “We Matter” mantra has stuck.

This photograph was taken from Riverview Park in Carson City. Do you see one mountain range or two?

Beginning now through Nov. 26, KNVC 91.5 FM Carson City community radio in conjunction with Chef Charlie Abowd, are collecting non-perishable food for distribution to our community's food insecure.

Every month, Park Rangers offer various Ranger-Led programs that include educational opportunities, historical fun and exciting adventures. All programs are offered for free and take place in one of the many Carson City parks and open space areas.

The Carson City Symphony Association announces the ninth annual instrumental music scholarship for Carson City students age 5 to 17. The scholarship was established by a generous gift from Jennifer and John Webley in memory of Rosemary Nebesky, former board member and friend of the Carson City Symphony Association.

Here is the Carson City area road report for the week of Nov. 4-10, 2024. Closures are expected at the following locations due to road and utility work:

UPDATE 6:30PM: A Carson City teen, Larissa Rupert, reported missing, is now safe and unharmed after being contacted by deputies who were called to a residence, said Carson City Sheriff Ken Furlong.

Carson City Fire Department, sheriff's deputies and Nevada Highway Patrol were called late Saturday afternoon to a vehicle crash.

Graphics Extraordinaire 2024 has been a satisfying surprise for Western Nevada College Graphic Design Professor Jayna Conkey.

Although the new K-12 education funding formula that Nevada adopted five years ago significantly overhauled how state money flows down to public schools, school funding is still well below what experts think is needed to ensure good outcomes, according to a new report unveiled Wednesday by the Guinn Center, a policy-focused nonprofit research group.

Jodi Miller, Executive Director of the Night Off The Streets (NOTS) organization in Carson City, will join the Leisure Hour Club for their dinner meeting on Thursday, Nov. 14. She will discuss what NOTS does on a daily basis, how they help not only the unsheltered but the community as well, and the goals of the organization.

Culinary students at Carson Middle School will soon have some new tools in their kitchen. The program recently received a $5,000.00 grant from the Rotary Club of Carson City. Club members surprised Culinary Arts teacher Tammy Borremans, who applied for the grant, in her classroom earlier this week.

A storm system moved into the region overnight, bringing a few inches of snow to the Sierra and rain across the lower valleys.

Clear Creek Bowmen annual Turkey Shoot is this Sunday, Nov. 3 at the Carson City Archery Range, just East of Eagle Valley Golf Course. The event is open to the public.

The Capital City Arts Initiative presents "Ships of Nevada" by Wayne Scarpaci, an exhibition with paintings of USS ships, all related to Nevada.

Douglas County invites residents to an educational flood awareness workshop to discuss flood preparedness and current flood control projects.

The Nevada Treasury has announced the start of the open enrollment period for the Nevada Prepaid Tuition Program, beginning Nov. 1, 2024 and concluding on April 15, 2025. The structured savings plan program allows Nevada families to explore payment options for college tuition and allows students to secure the price of in-state tuition early.