No Room for Faithless Electors

Ten years from now, you probably won't remember Christopher Suprun.

Suprun was chosen by the Texas Republican Party for the Electoral College. For most of our nation's history, this has been a procedural and honorary duty conferred upon loyal activists within the political parties when their presidential candidate carried their state.

But now Mr. Suprun is creating his 15 minutes of fame via a column in the New York Times in which he says he will not vote for Donald Trump and calls on other electors to follow suit. Of course, the Times' far-left management and readership are thrilled as they thrash about for any way to invalidate election results they don't like.

They claim the Electoral College was intended to be a deliberative body and should again become so. Since Trump’s election, our leftist friends have also discovered that the Constitution intentionally places strict limitations on the powers of the presidency. How convenient! We've warned continuously about the consolidation of power for decades, spanning both Republican and Democrat administrations, without previously finding a receptive audience from them.

It's only partly true that the Electoral College was ever a deliberative body. Originally, voters didn't vote directly for president, but chose from among a slate of electors who would subsequently meet together in their respective states and cast their own votes for president. This gave the electors some level of discretion in representing their constituents, but the entire Electoral College never actually met together and deliberated, since the Constitution specifically requires that electors meet within "their respective states."

Further, the scope of agency granted to electors in the early republic was fundamentally different than today. In the early days, suffrage was restricted to property-owning males. The prevailing view of the founders was that taxpayers should control the direction of government in much the same way that stockholders directed corporations. Most taxes were based on property and each married couple was viewed as a single accounting unit, which was the basis of their rationale for restricting suffrage to property-owning men.

Coincidentally, this cohort tended to be more highly educated and informed than the general population. Similarly, the allegiances and affiliations of prospective electors were widely known among this elite group. So when voters chose electors, they generally knew with whom they were aligned.

It's fortunate that we now vote directly for president, because it would be difficult for voters to know the personal affiliations of prospective electors in a nation nearly 100 times as large and with universal suffrage. That's why electors are now chosen directly by the parties, making their affiliations unquestioned.

But the change in format also implies a change in the scope of agency granted to the electors. And this is the real hang-up for those now trying to subvert this year's election results.

Agency is a centuries-old field of law that codifies the legal rights and obligations of parties to a principal-agent relationship or third parties transacting with an agent.

Most of us have been agents in some capacity. As employees, we are agents of the firm we work for, but we are only permitted to create obligations on the firm insomuch as we have been given authority to do so. Authority to bind the principal can be express or implied, but this determination is governed by the context, history and commonly observed business practices in a particular industry. Further, we also must follow the direct orders of those we represent, or they may rightfully fire us and end the agency.

Considering the political history, the scope of agency given to presidential electors no longer includes discretionary powers to vote for a candidate of their personal choice. As the collective principal, voters now expressly confirm their desire by directly choosing a specific candidate they intend the elector to support.

If Mr. Suprun were to exercise such wanton behavior in a business setting, his employer might legally repudiate his actions and he'd be personally liable for their consequences.

We don't believe in subverting elections, even when we dislike the outcome. And we certainly disdain anyone who abuses their agency to support such an effort.

We look forward to Mr. Suprun and his enablers disappearing in history’s rear-view mirror.

Ron Knecht is Nevada Controller. Geoffrey Lawrence is Assistant Controller.

Top Stories

... or see all stories

Big Lots, Inc. (OTC: BIG) announced today store location 4215 S Carson St. Carson City, NV 8970, previously scheduled for closure, will remain open. The decision is part of the company’s ongoing restructuring process aimed at enhancing customer experience and refining its market presence.

Sen. Jacky Rosen (D-NV) has won Nevada’s U.S. Senate race, fending off a challenge from Army veteran Sam Brown in a contest closer than polls had projected to represent the Silver State for a second term.

Join us for Carson City's High Water Mark Unveiling Ceremony next Thursday Nov. 14 from 2:00pm-4:00pm at Morgan Mill River Access. There will be interactive stations, guided walks, flood information and discussion and more.

Secondary school administrators at Carson MS, Eagle Valley MS, and Carson and Pioneer High School in Carson City chose a support called Check and Connect to implement a system of mentorship provided by school staff.

The intervention is a Tier 2 approach in the Multi-Tiered System of Supports (MTSS) for schools to address and support attendance and academic success in school.

Meet Katie, the sweetest and wiggliest pup you'll ever encounter! This adorable bundle of joy will have you smiling from ear to ear as soon as you call her name, because Katie has a unique way of showing her excitement—her whole rear end wiggles with delight!

As of 5 p.m. Wednesday, Nov. 6, here are the election results. We will continue to update the master election story which you can view here as results continue to be updated.

According to the Secretary of State's Office, 65.63% of registered voters in the capital city came out to cast their ballots, the majority of which utilized early voting (44.69%), followed by mail-in ballots (43.28%), and finally rounding out the last of the voters on election day (12.03%).

Carson Tahoe Health will host a Community Health Fair this Saturday, Nov. 9 from 9 a.m. to noon at Carson Tahoe Regional Medical Center, 1600 Medical Parkway in Carson City.

NV Energy is reporting power outages Wednesday afternoon in areas around Carson City. As of 2 p.m. there are 165 customers without power. The cause is under investigation. Go here for updates from NV Energy.

Carson City unofficial figures updated Wednesday, Nov. 6, 4 p.m. (Still awaiting updated Carson City numbers, which were last updated around 10 a.m. Wednesday morning)

While time is up for the polls, which were scheduled to close at 7 p.m., if voters were in line before the cut off they will be allowed to vote. We will update the results as they come in. Carson City polls could take a couple hours to turn in their results.

Please be aware that mail-in ballots are being accepted as long as they were postmarked by election day, today, Nov. 5. This means that we will continue to see more results in the days to come, which is anticipated and expected.

Carson City Symphony Assoc. presents "Cello Fest"

The Carson City Symphony Assoc. presents "Cello Fest: On and Off the Page with Sera Smolen" on Saturday, November 16, 2024, from 9:00 a.m. to 3:00 p.m. at Eagle Valley Middle School, 4151 E. 5th Street, Carson City.

Join Artsy Fartsy Art Gallery in Carson City this Saturday, Nov. 9, beginning at 11 a.m. as we begin our celebration of the holiday season. the gallery will be filled with beautiful local artwork and amazing gift ideas.

Each year the Nevada Artists Association is pleased to present the Pat Holub Award from the entries in the judged Nevada Day Show. This year the recipient of the award is Alanna McDaniel for her mixed media piece, "The Good Dog."

Nevada voters have rejected the most significant proposed change to the state’s election system since mail-in ballots were implemented in 2020.

The next Carson City Board of Supervisors meeting will be held Thursday, Nov. 7, beginning at 8:30 a.m. in the Bob Crowell Board Room of the Community Center located at 851 E. William St.

"Growing up with parents who are teachers means having a constant stream of knowledge, curiosity and a love for learning instilled in you." (Unknown).

This week’s senior in the spotlight, Sawyer Macy would agree with this statement. Born to two educators, it is no surprise that Sawyer has found himself a lifelong learner. As a result, he is an excellent student and a talented athlete.

Join Carson High Safe Grad for a Fun Run on the Carson River trail behind the Korean War Veterans Memorial Park for Veteran's Day, Monday Nov, 11, 2024 beginning at 9 a.m.

The course is easy & flat for beginners and wide enough for advanced runners. Off-road strollers and dogs on leashes welcome. Kids age 10 & under FREE. Visit the link here to register now!

Missing Link Network Hub Invitation

Missing Link Network is an exclusive referral networking organization for business professionals, entrepreneurs, and corporate executives. Each group restricts membership to one seat per industry, ensuring a collaborative, non-competitive environment where members share referrals, expertise, and accountability.

Lyon County Sheriff's Office detectives traveled to the state of Utah where they arrested Robert Richards for the murder of Sara Filiatraut. Since that time, Richards has been in custody in Utah pending extradition to Lyon County.

Here are the recent births that occurred at Carson Tahoe Hospital between Oct. 27 - Nov. 1, 2024.

In the 2020 election, President Joe Biden was not declared the winner of Nevada’s electoral votes until four days after Election Day.

Is it possible we’ll have to wait that long again?

Mt. Rose Ski Tahoe will be the first Tahoe area resort to kick off the 2024-25 winter season when it opens Friday, Nov. 8. Early season snow, ideal temperatures that have allowed the resort to fire up its extensive snowmaking system.

Carson City Community Development is partnering with the Northern Nevada Development Authority and Nevada Rural Housing to offer free real estate agent training about NRH’s first-time homebuyer programs. The training will occur on Wednesday, Nov. 13, from 11:30 a.m. to 1 p.m. at Adams Hub, 111 W. Proctor St. Lunch will be provided.

Lyon County became aware on Oct. 19 that a major design flaw had occurred at the Aspen Creek Rapid Infiltration Basins project, and as a result, all development is currently being halted within the Dayton Sewer Service Area, according to Taylor Allison, the county's emergency management and government affairs director.

It isn’t too early to think about Western Nevada College’s Spring 2025 semester. New, continuing and returning students can make plans for the next semester now.

A 26-year-old man was arrested Saturday for suspicion of felony eluding, misdemeanor second offense DUI and other offenses following an early morning vehicle pursuit, according to a Carson City Sheriff's Office booking report.

UPDATE 9AM: Carson City Fire Department and sheriff's deputies responded Tuesday morning to a vehicle crash involving a student pedestrian on North Saliman Road near Carson High School.

Carson City voters lined up to Tuesday morning to cast their ballots at the Community Center and at the Stewart Colony Wellness and Gym for the 2024 General Election.

Nevada Highway Patrol has identified two people from Fernley who died in a crash Oct. 24 on US-50A and Wedge Lane in Lyon County.

Volunteer signups are underway for Carson High Holiday Craft Fair. All hours worked directly benefit Carson High School and get you into the Craft Fair free following your shift.

YERINGTON — In response to a statement issued Friday by the Nevada Secretary of State’s Office, Lyon County Clerk/Treasurer Staci Lindberg confirms the Clerk’s Office was made aware on Friday, November 1st of an issue involving the placement of a portion of Lyon County Precinct 26 in an incorrect Assembly District.